A lawsuit filed in federal court alleges that the Community College of Baltimore County denied Brandon Jenkins entry to a radiation therapy program because of his Christian faith and was advised to not wear his religion on his sleeve.
David French, an attorney with the American Center for Law and Justice, has an email written to his client by Adrienne Dougherty, the director of the college’s radiation therapy program.
In the email Ms. Dougherty explains the reasons behind why Jenkins was denied.
Click like if you support Christianity
She wrote that while his grades were good, there were other students with higher grade point averages. Applicants had to have a 2.5 overall GPA to be eligible. (At this point it seemed plausible that there were other candidates with higher averages.)
The college also took issue with his desire to stay in Maryland after he got his degree.
“I feel that I would be doing you a disservice if I allowed you into the program and you are not able to find a job based on your past,” she wrote.
Mr. French acknowledged that his client had a single criminal charge on his record that dated back more than 10 years. Early in the admission process, Mr. Jenkins asked if that would be a problem, and he was assured it would not hamper his effort.
But then – Ms. Dougherty dropped the bombshell, the lawsuit alleges.
“I understand that religion is a major part of your life and that was evident in your recommendation letters, however, this field is not the place for religion,” she wrote. “We have many patients who come to us for treatment from many different religions and some who believe in nothing at all.”
And then, Ms. Dougherty offered what I imagine in her mind must have been helpful advice in this age of tolerance and diversity.
“If you interview in the future, you may want to leave your thoughts and beliefs out of the interview process,” she wrote.
This field is not the place for religion.
Mr. French told Todd Starnes in a telephone conversation “I was astonished by the email. While colleges routinely discriminate against Christians, rarely do they state their discrimination so explicitly.”
A law firm representing the community college defended Ms. Dougherty’s statement in In a letter to the ACLJ.
“Stated bluntly, that is not bad advice,” attorney Peter Saucier wrote. “Mr. Jenkins was not advised to ignore, change or deny his religious views. The suggestion simply was that he not wear them on his sleeve as his best qualification.”
How does the college knew that Mr. Jenkins is a Christian?
During the interview process he was asked the following question:
What is the most important thing to you? According to the lawsuit.
Mr. Jenkins replied, “My God.”
Mr. French said there were no follow up questions and his client did not mention his religious beliefs. But that brief mention of God, coupled with recommendation letters that made references to faith, were enough to disqualify Mr. Jenkins from the program.
The college denied they discriminated against the man. Instead, they argue they were just trying to help him “refocus” and succeed.
“Her words may have been inartfully stated, but the fact is that in any secular job or program interview it is better to have a concrete reason for wanting to undertake the training at hand than to say only that God directed one to do it,” Mr. Saucier wrote to the ACLJ. “That is true for every job from astronaut to attorney.”
Todd Starnes at Fox News said “It sounds to me like the Community College of Baltimore County has a “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” religion policy.”
The ACLJ’s lawsuit alleges the college violated the Establishment Clause of the U.S. Constitution and they want their client granted admission to the radiation therapy program.
The college isn’t kicking him out of the school. Just ‘denying him placement in certain classes’.
Ms. Dougherty’s email also shows that she was offering him alternative degree paths. She went so far as to suggest he could work on a degree in mental health study and noted in her email that he would make a “great candidate.”
Four administrators are named in the ACLJ lawsuit: Sandra Kurtinitis, Richard Lilley, Mark McColloch and Adrienne Dougherty as defendants.